As more and more TV, music, and movie content has moved online, a veritable industry has grown up around helping people to circumvent location based broadcast restrictions. Demonstrating the scale of the issue, GlobalWatchIndex reports that as many as 29% of VPN users globally accessed Netflix in one recent month. Tutorials for how to access this and other streaming services abound.
Streaming providers are required by content licensors to geographically restrict access to the content they license. Providers risk losing content licensors’ trust and ultimately risk losing their ability to license content from studios and other licensors if they are not able to restrict access based on where their customers are accessing this content from. This post describes the ways restrictions are being bypassed and offers some advice on solutions.
A streaming content service that has the rights to show a given movie exclusively to viewers in the US will use an IP address geolocation filter to block viewing by those outside the country. In order to bypass this restriction, an individual located outside the US need only identify a VPN or proxy service that offers access to an IP address that geolocates to the US. Once she signs up for VPN access, she accesses the movie service via the VPN and the content is unlocked.
Enterprising individuals have seized on this opportunity to meet the demand of those who want to access geo-restricted content. Using cloud-computing, it’s cheap and easy to set up a subscription-based VPN service in almost any region or country. Any traffic tunneled through these servers will geolocate to the IP address of the VPN server.
In the past, an IP geolocation country-level database was all one needed to perform digital rights management. However, with the growth of VPN services, more sophisticated solutions are additionally required to prevent unauthorized access to geo-restricted content.
Streaming content providers need to identify the use of VPNs and proxies (DNS, HTTP, TOR, etc.) to ensure that their content is not being accessed outside of contractually-negotiated areas. Fortunately, a wide swath of VPNs and proxies are not hard to identify. For example, publicly available WHOIS records will show you the registering organization of an IP address. If someone accessing your site is using an IP address that belongs to a hosting provider, this is a very strong indication that the person is using a VPN or proxy service. In some cases, the registering organization will be a VPN provider itself.
Users of the TOR network may cycle through IP addresses to obtain one that geolocates to a country of interest. Within the context of the TOR network, these IP addresses are known as “exit nodes”. A complete list of exit nodes is available for download.
Compiling a list of known web hosts and VPN providers and comparing them to TOR lists and the WHOIS records of connecting IP addresses can be tedious.
Also, while they can identify many VPNs and proxies, WHOIS and TOR lists will not capture the increasingly popular DNS and web-based proxies, which are favored for providing faster access to streaming content. New services pop up daily and public data is usually stale. This is why content licensors require use of additional methods to ensure effective detecting geofiltering beyond traditional IP geolocation.
We created the GeoIP2 Anonymous IP database to assist content licensees in meeting their geofiltering contract requirements while addressing their needs for a low-latency solution. Our GeoIP2 Anonymous IP database identifies IP addresses such that are likely to be used for circumventing geolocation restrictions, including TOR exit nodes, hosting, VPN, and DNS proxy IPs. To keep pace with the creation of new VPN and proxy services, this database is updated daily.
Streaming providers, contractually required to restrict access to content based on location, need new tools in addition to standard IP geolocation filters to keep up with those trying to access their restricted content. Public WHOIS and TOR data can be used to identify some IPs used by VPN and proxy services, in particular when these services are run on web hosts. Identifying these and other proxies and keeping up with their creation requires using a service like MaxMind’s GeoIP2 Anonymous IP database.